Half-way Through Harry (Potter That Is)

I fully realize that I am behind the times, but at least I am catching up.  I am finally reading Harry Potter.  There are a couple of reasons for this: 1)  My oldest grandson is reading them and I wanted to be able to talk with him about the books.  2)  Many of my students and a couple of my small group girls are major fans and I decided I should have some idea what they are talking about.  I just finished Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire.  Book-wise I am more than half-way, but page-wise, not so much.  They just get longer and longer!

To be completely honest, I read the first one several years ago.  I had heard a lot of talk pro and con about the series and I wanted to read them for myself.  At that time my conclusion was that there was nothing evil about them but that they were not on par with Narnia as far as great literature either.  I still agree with my previous conclusion.  I do think the writing and plot line improves as this series goes along which is unusual. (Consider Twilight.–No, don’t. It’s too painful.)

I started over this time with the first volume and I bought the books.  This is a sign of commitment in a book-freak like me.  I have found lots of neat ideas, posted a few quotes as facebook statuses and one or two are even worthy of my commonplace book.  I love the fact that a modern author recognizes that good and evil exist.  I like the views portrayed about the importance of things like love and sacrifice and loyalty.  I like Harry and his friends.  They are good characters. I love Dumbledore.

At the risk of censure, however, I must address one thing about the books that really bothers me.  Before I do, let me say that I am not presenting this as a reason not to read them.  They are REALLY good.  I think all literature should be read critically in the sense that it should be evaluated in the light of biblical truth.  As I have said before, even at less than the half-way point, I have found much truth. As we read, we should be asking ourselves questions.  Is this true?  Should he do that?  What would be the right thing to do?  Why did she make that decision?  What led to this tragedy?  Asking questions helps us learn.  We may read for entertainment, but reading should not be simply an amusement.  (Amusement means “without thinking.”)

Here’s my struggle:  Harry and his friends break rules constantly.  They break rules in order to solve mysteries and right wrongs.  Sometimes adults even help them to do this in a secretive way.  Dumbledore, whom I have already professed to love, gives Harry the invisibility cloak.  This smacks a bit of an “end justifies the means” philosophy.  At the very least, Harry and his friends seem to think themselves above the rules as Professor Snape, who I am supposed to hate but with whom I’m afraid I sometimes sympathize, loves to point out.  I think Snape will turn out to be okay in the end.  Dumbledore seems to think so, and I love Dumbledore.

Our whole society seems to think that rules are made to be broken.  There is also a prevalent idea that if you are not caught breaking a rule, you have done nothing wrong.  Further, many people believe that if they think a rule is dumb or unfair, or if they have a REALLY good reason for breaking a rule, this lets them off obeying it.  I know this.  I teach at a school.  There is also a lot of animosity towards the teachers at Hogwarts who enforce the rules while those who continually bend them or look the other way are loved.  I guess the exception would be Professor McGonagall.  She seems to be a lovable rule enforcer.  Anyway, all of this leads to a situation in which everyone does what is right in their own eyes, and we all know as well as Noah where that can lead.

This is where I see a difference between Rowling and Lewis, Potter and Narnia.  People who break rules in the Narnia stories hear about it from Aslan.  When Aravis drugs her slave in The Horse and His Boy so that she can escape, the slave is beaten for oversleeping.  Aslan scratches Aravis so that her wounds are identical to those of her maid.  He says she “needed to know what it felt like.”  He makes it clear that his actions are done in love, to teach her and to prepare her for the role she is to have as a queen.  She needs to think about how her actions impact others.  This is the way of Aslan.  He disciplines in love, and then he moves on.

I think Aslan is the major difference in the stories.  Aslan provides a solid answer to the “why” questions.  Harry has an answer too.  So far, I think the answer is love.  Love as a concept is not as strong, however, as love personified.  I’m only half-way through.  Maybe it’s coming.  I hope so, but I’ll keep reading and learning and enjoying.  It’s good and besides, I love Dumbledore.


This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Half-way Through Harry (Potter That Is)

  1. deborah Buonocore says:

    I enjoyed Harry Potter at the urging of a student, WAY before it was a “hot ticket” (At the time, the second one wasn’t even in print.) It was the first fantasy/sci-fi I had EVER liked enough to finish. Since then, others of the genre has been consumed … I like to read it to my students with various British accents, too!


  2. Dear Mrs. Liebmann,
    You’ve always reminded me of McGonagall. It”s great. Can I come by and see you at school in the next few weeks? When will you have time?


  3. Well, I’m still struggling through the first one, becaue it never gripped me. I will say this about the series after reading your post. I think somewhere Satan got us Christians off on broomsticks and spells with regard to the series when those really weren’t the problems at all, just at lot of hocus pocus. Your points on the other hands on the blurring of good and evil are far greater concern and people snoozed through it while chasing their windmills.(Forgive the mixed metaphors).


    • lellielieb says:

      I agree. I think Christians can go both ways–disapproving of books before really considering their whole content and putting their stamp of approval on others for some small virtue before considering the whole. I can’t tell you how many people have declared to me that the Twilight books are “Christian” because the characters do’t sleep together before they are married. Well, how about the fact that Bella is a whiney brat who tries to seduce Edward constantly and treats Jacob, her true friend, like dirt because of her obsession? ( None of that has anything to do with the fact that there are vampires and werewolves in the books.)While we MUST read critically and not read things that rot our brains, I think that if Christians are familiar with the scripture, they can read any true literature and learn from it. All literature is flawed since it is written by man. The scripture is the only inspired Word of God.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s